Hidden Voices: Enslaved Women in the Lowcountry and U.S. South

Exhibit Splash Image

Exploitation through Sexual Violence

Illustration of an enslaved woman, E.W. Kemble, from Uncle Tom's Cabin, Harriet Beecher Stowe, 1891, courtesy of The Institute for Advanced Technology in the Humanities.

Illustration of an enslaved woman, E.W. Kemble, from Uncle Tom's Cabin, Harriet Beecher Stowe, 1891, courtesy of The Institute for Advanced Technology in the Humanities.

Under bondage, women faced multiple forms of sexual abuse from slaveholders, and the rape of enslaved women was not a crime in any slaveholding state. Sometimes this involved physical violence, while at other times men used different methods to cajole women into sexual relationships, including the promise of material benefits or threatening sale if women failed to consent. Sexual exploitation of enslaved women can be situated on a spectrum of experiences that overlapped or changed for each woman who experienced it, ranging from violent penetrative rape to other forms of sexual harassment to formalized concubinage. Just as men’s sexual harassment varied so did enslaved women’s responses to it. 

Physical punishment was sometimes extremely violent and could result from women’s refusal of slaveholders’ sexual advances. Minnie Fulkes alluded to this violence when interviewed by the WPA. She suggested an overseer tied up and whipped her mother because she refused to be “a wife” to this man. Fulkes hence rather opaquely conveys how her mother’s refusal of the overseer’s sexual advances led to this punishment:

Illustration of both male and female enslavers beating an enslaved African American woman, from Narrative of the Life and Adventures of Henry Bibb, An American Slave, Written by Himself, 1849, courtesy of Documenting the South.

Illustration of both male and female enslavers beating an enslaved African American woman, from Narrative of the Life and Adventures of Henry Bibb, An American Slave, Written by Himself, 1849, courtesy of Documenting the  American South.

"Honey, I don’t like to talk about them times, because my mother did suffer misery. You know there was an overseer who used to tie mother up in the barn with a rope around her arms up over her head, while she stood on a block. Soon as they got her tied, this block was moved and her feet dangled, you know, couldn’t touch the floor. This old man, now, would start beating her naked until the blood run down her back to her heels. I took and seed the welts and scars for my own self with these two eyes. Was a whip like they used to use on horses, it was a piece of leather about as wide as my hand from little finger to thumb…. I asked mother ‘what she done for them to beat and do her so?’ She said, 'nothing. Other than she refused to be wife to this man."

Minnie Fulkes, interview with Federal Writers' Project, Virginia, 1937.

Many women were unable to escape enslavers’ sexual assault, particularly without being beaten as a result. Women who labored in plantation homes were at particular risk of sexual predators because they worked in close proximity to white men. A sexual assault victim as she entered just her fifteenth year, Harriet Jacobs described her disgust for her enslaver and mentioned her attempts to turn to her mistress—fictionalized as Mrs. Flint, but whose real name was Mary Norcom—for support. Instead, her jealous mistress responded with hostility and anger. Norcom’s response was typical of white women who regarded the real victims of sexual violence as Jezebels, the invented hypersexualized persona whites ascribed to enslaved women. Jacobs penned her experience as a fifteen-year-old girl with her slaveholders:

Portrait of Harriet Jacobs, photograph by C.M. Gilbert, Washington, D.C., 1894, courtesy Wikimedia Commons. Cover page of <em>Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl,</em> Harriet A. Jacobs, 1861, courtesy of Documenting the American South, University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill.

(Top) Portrait of Harriet Jacobs, photograph by C.M. Gilbert, Washington, D.C., 1894, courtesy of Wikimedia Commons. (Bottom) Cover page of Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl, Harriet A. Jacobs, 1861, courtesy of Documenting the American South.

"He was a crafty man, and resorted to many ways to accomplish his purposes. Sometimes he had stormy, terrific ways that made his victims tremble; sometimes he assumed a gentleness that he thought must surely subdue. Of the two, I preferred his stormy moods, although they left me trembling. He tried his utmost to corrupt the pure principles my grandmother had instilled. He peopled my young mind with unclean images, such as only a vile monster could think of. I turned from him with disgust and hatred. But he was my master. I was compelled to live under the same roof with him – where I saw a man forty years my senior daily violating the most sacred commandments of nature. He told me I was his property; that I must be subject to his will in all things. My soul revolted against the mean tyranny. But where could I turn for protection? No matter whether the slave girl be as black as ebony or as fair as her mistress. In either case, there is no shadow of law to protect her from insult, from violence, or even from death; all these are inflicted by fiends who bear the shape of men. The mistress, who ought to protect the helpless victim, has no other feelings towards her but those of jealousy and rage…"

Harriet Jacobs, Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl (New York: Dover, 2001 [1861]), 44-45.

The diary of Keziah Brevard, a white woman writing during the Civil War, illustrates the contradictory and racist ideas white society held about Black women. They demanded Black women submit themselves to sexual violence for the pleasure of male enslavers and to bear children as future laborers while also degrading Black women by defining them as immoral for the very actions whites demanded of them:

"They are not prepared for freedom, many of them set no higher value on themselves than the beasts of the field do. I know a family in five miles of me where there are six women who have and have had children for thirty years back and not one of them but [have] been bastards and only one ever had a husband… I own many slaves and many of the females are of the lowest cast – making miserable their own fellow servants by meddling with the husbands of others  -- I am not excusing the males, but in the world they are not so degraded by such conduct as the females."

John Hammond Moore, (ed.), A Plantation Mistress on the Eve of the Civil War: The Diary of Keziah Goodwyn Hopkins Brevard, 1860-1861 (Columbia; University of South Carolina Press, 1993), 39.

Enslaved women’s responses to the sexual advances of white men varied. Some fought back, regardless of the consequences of their actions. Others acquiesced in an attempt at self-preservation. Overall the sheer volume of surviving testimony about such a private, personal, and stressful phenomenon—alongside the fact that so many enslaved women gave birth to the children of their masters—is testament to the fact that such abuse by white men in a variety of positions was widespread. Enslaved in South Carolina, WPA respondent Gus Feaster recalled the plantation overseer, Wash Evans, as a "wicked man" who "take ‘vantage of all de slaves:

"One day Missus sent my mammy and the other old lady Lucy to fetch her some blackberries by dinner. Me and John was with them a picking and filling all the big buckets from the little buckets when old man Evans come riding up. He argued with both mammy and old lady Lucy and they keep telling him that the missus wants her berries and that they was religious women anyhow and didn’t practice no life of sin and vile wickedness. Finally he got down off of his horse and pull out his whip and Lord if they didn’t submit to him then he going to beat them half to death… Finally they act like they going in the wickedness with that old man. But when he took off his whip and some other garments, my mammy and old lady Lucy grab him by his goatee and further down and hoist him over in the middle of them blackberry bushes. With that they call me and John. Us grab all the buckets and us all put out for the big house fast as our legs could carry us."

Gus Feaster, interview with Federal Writers' Project, South Carolina, 1937.

Photograph of two biracial children and their mother, M.H. Kimball, New Orleans, Louisiana, 1863, courtesy of Library of Congress.

Photograph of two biracial children and their mother, M.H. Kimball, New Orleans, Louisiana, 1863, courtesy of Library of Congress.

For women unable to escape sexual advances and violence of white men, the results could be very difficult for mothers and children. Ryer Emmanuel recalls the plantation mistress’ reaction to one of the enslaved children born with “yellow skin” and “straight hair.”

“All the other children was black skin with this here kinky hair, and she was yellow skin with right straight hair. My Lord, old Missus been mighty proud of her black children, but she also sure been touchy about that yellow one. I remember, all us children was playing round about the step one day where Miss Ross was sitting, and she ask that yellow child, say, ‘Who your papa?’ The child never known no better, and she tell her right out exactly the one her mammy had told her was her papa. Lord, Miss Ross, she say, ‘Well, get off my step. Get off and stay off there cause you don’t noways belong to me.’ The poor child, she cry and she cry so hard until her mammy never know what to do.”

Ryer Emmanuel, interview with Federal Writers' Project, South Carolina, 1937.

The fate of the little girl is not recorded. Considering the disdain expressed about her by the wife of her enslaver, "Miss Ross," the girl was likely continually subjected to verbal assaults, sold away, learned to stay out of the eyesight of the white family, or a combination of these. In all cases, though, the mother and child were place in an impossible position with the white slaveholding family.

White men and women were complicit slaveholders. Even as white women expressed anger towards enslaved women and their children, they served as “co-masters” by supporting their husbands and gaining economic and social benefits from owning slaves. When white men or women were violent towards enslaved women, they saw it as part of the necessary order of their world. Ignoring enslaved women’s unwillingness to participate in sexual acts, many white men cataloged their assaults as simply part of their paternalistic purview. One slaveholder, suspecting himself of having children with multiple women he enslaved, wholly disregarded the impact his assault had on women when he wrote of his exploits:

"Sally says Henderson is my child. It is possible but I do not believe it… Louisa’s first child may be mine. I think not. Her second I believe is mine… Do not let Louisa or any of my children or possible children by slaves of strangers. Slavery in the family will be the happiest earthly condition."

James Henry Hammond, Letter to Henry Hammond [son], February 1856. Hammond-Bryan-Cumming  family papers, South Caroliniana Library, Columbia, SC.

Sexually exploited women were left assaulted and sometimes pregnant by enslavers or overseers. Their trauma was worsened because they knew that they had little ability to protect themselves from harm in the future. When they did bear enslavers’ children, they had an extremely limited ability to keep their child safe or keep them from being sold away. Their exploitation served the egos and whims of the enslavers or overseers, who most often treated Black women as objects, not humans. The exploitation of their bodies continued with enslavers’ demands that they reproduce to ensure a subsequent generation of forced, bonded labor.